Article from Bean's Trees and Shrubs Hardy in the British Isles
Recommended citation
'Mahonia' from the website Trees and Shrubs Online (treesandshrubsonline.
Mahonia is united with Berberis by many botanists, the two being consistently separable only by leaf morphology (Berberis: simple; Mahonia: pinnate). As traditionally circumscribed, Mahonia has been found to be polyphyletic. Some authorities resolve this problem by subsuming the entire genus into Berberis (see e.g. POWO 15/4/2025), but there are good horticultural, ecological and evolutionary reasons for wanting to maintain two separate genera. Recent molecular research indicates that a monophyletic classification can be achieved differently – without sinking Mahonia into Berberis – if Mahonia sect. Horridae (consisting of xeric species from the western USA) is referred to the new genus Alloberberis C.C.Yu & F.K.Chung (Yu & Chung 2017). (The transferral of Berberis claireae to another new genus, Moranothamnus, achieves the same monophyletic result for Berberis.) See also the entry for Alloberberis.
A genus of evergreen shrubs very closely related to Berberis and often united with it. They are very distinct in their invariably evergreen character, in their simply pinnate foliage and in the absence of spines from their branches. In his monograph on Berberis and Mahonia Dr Ahrendt pointed out a further distinction: ‘that three-quarters of the species of Mahonia possess a form of inflorescence never found in the simple-leaved Berberis, a fascicle of several dense spike-like racemes. Only a minority share a Berberis-like form of inflorescence’. (The exceptions are all American species, in which the inflorescence is a panicle, a simple raceme or a few-flowered umbellate cluster.)
The genus contains some very handsome species, the usually prickly-margined leaves being dark and shining. They are not generally so hardy as the true barberries, but those that are hardy are amongst the handsomest of evergreens. All thrive in a good garden soil. The generic name commemorates Bernard M’Mahon, an American horticulturist who died in 1816. Over 100 species are recognised by Dr Ahrendt in his monograph.
The hardier cultivated mahonias are surveyed by H. J. van de Laar in Dendroflora No. 11/12, pp. 19–32 (1975).